My name is Thomas Harold Edelson. Welcome to my journal.
To repeat the most important sentence from my profile:
Spiritually, I am some combination of Quaker, Taoist, and pagan.
My name is Thomas Harold Edelson. Welcome to my journal.
To repeat the most important sentence from my profile:
Spiritually, I am some combination of Quaker, Taoist, and pagan.
To get oriented: I am calling this entry The Materialists View. The materialists view about what?
Answer: about how it came to be that people perceive beauty in the world.
In the previous entry, I told you what I thought about how fundamentalist Christians would answer that question. So now, I am going to say how I think materialists would answer it.
So what do I mean by materialists?
In some contexts, a materialist denotes someone who cares only about material things: they wish to accumulate money, and objects that have high monetary value.
I intend to use materialist in a different sense, one roughly equivalent to empiricist.
Okay, what's an empiricist?
In philosophical jargon, an empiricist is someone who believes that the only truths are those that can be established empirically. The foundational example of that: you see it with your own eyes.
But in philosophy, this tends to be used in an expanded sense. One may confidently believe something that one hasnt seen with ones own eyesand couldnt have, because it hasnt happened yet.
What youve done is to predict it. A number of previous events have been noticed to occur, and conditions to obtain. It has also been noticed, usually by others, that when these preconditions hold, a certain type of event usually follows. Sometimes these observed general patterns come to be called scientific laws.
Once its been sufficiently often observed, one can also run the logic and mathematics in reverse, and declare that the science has explained something which has already happened.
So in summation, an empiricist is one who believes:
Oh, and one more thing: that is an exhaustive list. If one claims to be an empiricist, one is declaring a world-view in which the above classes of propositions, and only those, will be believed.
Or at any rate, that is what I shall mean by the word empiricist, when I use it in this article.
Whew. Thats a lot of words expended on making up a local meaning for empiricist. But it was necessary (I thought); if I had not done it, you would not have been in a position to understand my attempts to answer the question before usnamely, What would an empiricist say about how it came to be that (some) people perceive beauty in the world?
At any rate, it is time for me to try to answer that.
The answer could be expressed in two words: Not much. That is, an empiricist, when speaking purely as an empiricist, would have no particular answer to How come some people perceive beauty?
Or in other words different empiricists might answer the same question in wildly different ways. One of them might reply: Why are you asking me? If you want to know how the human race evolved to perceive (at least some of) the world as beautiful, you need to be asking an evolutionary biologist, or a psychologist, or somone like that.
On the other hand, if you put the same question to someone who actually is an evolutionary biologist, you might get a long, thoughtful (and confident) answer. Or, still another possibility: the reply might be along the lines of, Some interesting theories about that have been published, but no consensus has been reached.
To put that last paragraph in still other words: if you ask me, Tom Edelson, what a specialist in the subject would say, I would plead ignorance, because I'm not that sort of specialist myself. I am in the same position as the person described in the previous paragraph: like that person, I do consider myself to be an empiricist, but I dont think that having that general world-view necessarily carries with it any answers to the multitude of Why? questions (or, as in this case, the subclass of those which ask how a particular state of affairs came to be).
Let me repeat the central question (for this particular journal entry), and then summarize how I have answered it.
In repeating the question, I shall separate it into two parts: the inner question and the outer question.
The inner question: How did it come to be that (some) people perceive beauty in the world?
The outer question: if you posed the inner question to an empiricist, what answer would you get?
Answer: it depends on which empiricist you ask. At least some of them would answer I don't know.
(I'd like to think that that is the answer you would get from most empiricists but I am not sure that it is. Why would I like to think it? Because I believe that most empiricists actually dont know the answer. (They have never even thought about it; I certainly hadnt, before I started writing this journal entry.) And since I think they dont know, I would prefer to give them the benefit of the doubt, and assume that they are honest enough to admit that they dont know.)
Well, it may be only some empiricists who dont know the answer (and who may admit that they dont), or it may be most, but it certainly isn't all of them. Some claim, more or less plausibly, to have discovered at least part of the answer. But the important thing to remember about those guys is that whatever knowledge they do have about the subject, they did not gain it simply by virtue of being empiricists. They gained it by virtue of knowledge of some more specialized scientific field, such as how evolution works. So empiricism itself does not contain, nor even imply, the answer to our inner question.
And the reason why that is important, in turn, is that it is so starkly different from the results we got in the previous journal entry, where we posed the very same inner question to a different group of people, namely, fundamentalist Christians. Those fine folks were much more confident of their ability to answer the question. How did it come about that people are able to perceive the beauty in the world? Thats easy! God gave them that ability, as a gift.
And then .
We are brought straightaway to another new question, namely, how that difference, in turn, is to be explained. Why is it, with this inner question and others like it, that fundamentalists, as compared to empiricists, are much more likely to think that they know the answers?
I will address this question in the next journal entry.
Edit 2026-10-03: I have changed two things in this journal entry, since initially posting it on September 13:
How did there come into being a world, which has people in it, who think that the world is beautiful?
Is that the question I have tasked myself to answer? Not exactly.
My job is to answer two questions. Both of them are meta-questions, that is, they are questions about the original question (namely, How did there come into being a world ).
Here, then, are the two meta-questions.
First, how would the original question be answered by people who held a fundamentalist (aka Biblical literalist) Christian set of beliefs?
Second, how would that same question be answered by people who did not hold any monotheistic beliefs?
Way back in the first entry in this series, I described the second group of people as Taoists. Now, I am substituting a more general description: designating a larger set of people, which includes Taoists as a subset.
We have our questions; how about some answers?
I think its relatively easy to imagine what the Christians answer might be. (Perhaps its easier because I dont feel a need to provide an exact wording of the answer: after all, answers you would get in real life would undoubtedly vary.) So something like the following might be sufficient for our purposes.
What do you think? Would at least some sorts of Christians feel at home with an answer like that?
I still owe you my conjecture about how non-monotheists would answer the same question. But that does feel like a separate undertaking.
SoSurely youre not surprised?I'm going to make you wait for it.
Lets call to mind where I left things at the end of the last journal entry.
I began by abruptly changing the subject (again). I said, in effect, Maybe its premature to be trying to answer why the world is beautiful, because maybe folks dont all believe that the world is beautiful in the first place.
But then, perversely, I said that I also wasnt willing to discuss the question of whether the world actually is beautiful, either. My excuse? I claimed that the question was unanswerable: that the statement The world is beautiful is neither true nor false.
I acknowledged that the neither true nor false claim (whatever it might mean) is, itself, controversial. But then, rather than try to convince you of its truth, I (metaphorically) left the room, saying that you would need to wait for the next journal entry before youd get any more out of me. (Maybe I was just tired?)
So here we are at the next journal entry. Am I now going to prove to you that the sentence, The world is beautiful, is neither true nor false?
Not prove it, no. But I will offer you some reasons to think that the claim is not as outrageous as it (might have) seemed at first.
Imagine a situation in which you might actually utter the sentence The world is beautiful. Perhaps you are setting out to visit your favorite park.
Then something disappointing happens. For example, your vehicle runs out of fuel on the way there.
The chances are that, at that point, youd be less likely to say The world is beautiful again. You might even say, Gee, the world doesn't feel as beautiful now.
I know, I put my thumb on the scale by using the word feel. But consider. If The world is beautiful is to be construed as an assertion about how the world actually is, then its a very general assertion, indeed. A person in a rational state of mind would not change his belief about the truth-value of such a general assertion, just because his car ran out of gas.
The experience might very well, however, change how he felt about the world, at that moment. Feelings are like that: they very often do change in response to eventssometimes, change quite disproportionately to the degree of change in the state of the real world.
You could have used different words in your response to the out-of-fuel incident. You could have said, I was wrong. The world isnt beautiful, after all. By supposing that you said, instead, that it doesnt feel as beautiful as it did, I credited you with being more rationalor in a more rational frame of mindthan if you had phrased it the other way.
Like I said, it isnt a proof. But it may provide some small support for the suggestion that
When you pronounce a sentence using a value-laden word, such as beautiful,
the speech act you have performed may, at least sometimes, be more accurately categorized as expressing your feelings, rather than as asserting a proposition that is either true or false.
Whew. Where does that leave us? Well, you know the drill. It leaves me wanting to propose yet another change, or two, in the question we should pursue going forward. For now, I will pose the new question in its (relatively) simple form:
How did there come into being a world, in which exist large numbers of people who (at least sometimes) believe, or feel, that that world is beautiful?
Stay tuned.
On July 17, I posted a journal entry with the subject line, Why is the World Beautiful?
Now, imagine that I had not posted that. But that somebody else posted an entry with the same title. (Or posed the same question in a private email to me.)
How would I have responded to that?
I probably would have said: Sorry, I dont feel that I should even discuss that question, because it has a false (or at least doubtful) presupposition.
To which X, the person who asked the question in the first place, might reasonably reply, Whats false about it?
I reply, It presupposes that the world is beautiful.
X: Oh. Well, if youre doubtful about that, we could discuss that questionwhether the world is, in fact, beautifulinstead.
I: Sorry to be so difficult, but no. I dont think that its possible to have a rational discussion about that question.
X: My goodness, why not?
I: Because the sentence ‘The world is beautiful isnt an assertion of fact: what it says cannot, by its nature, be true, nor can it be false.
X: What does ‘The world is beautiful mean, then?
I: Its an expression of how one feels at the moment about the world.
My good friend X might very well not, at that point, consider the matter settled. What I have just claimedthat if you say, The world is beautiful, you are (merely?) expressing your own feelingsis very far from being universally accepted as the truth. (But it isnt just something I myself made up, either.)
In other words, a discussion along these lines could reasonably continue. But Ive dragged you around a lot of twists and turns, and so a restfor me, and perhaps for yall as wellseems like a good idea.
In still other words, Im going to make you wait for yet another journal entry.
This continues the Why Is the World Beautiful? series, which began with my last journal entry.
One of the commenters there said, I wonder why beauty needs a reason. Im glad she brought that up, because it shows me that my own original question, Why Is the World Beautiful?, was not nearly as clear as I thought it was. So let me try to rectify that.
My main question, for this whole series of entries, is not really why, but how: How did the world come to be beautiful?
Imagine the entry to have begun by posing that question. That would have been followed, immediately, by the quotation from All Things Bright and Beautiful.
How does the quotation relate to the how question? It answers it. Its answer is right there in the last line: The Lord God made them all.
It would be entirely natural for a reader, at that point, to follow up by switching from the how question to the why question: Okay, thats settled. But why would God do that? Why, specifically, would He make them all beautiful?
You will note that the quotation does not, explicitly, answer that second question. But you might agree with the following hunch: that a typical, card-carrying Christian would be likely to answer it this way: Because He loves us.
One could follow that line of thought further, but I shall not. Why not? Because Im hunting different game. Its the how question, and not the why question, that I wish to pursue.
Or to be more precise: Im not looking for the answerthe correct answerto the how question. Not How did the world come to be beautiful?, but What do different groups of people, with different belief systems, think about how the world came to be beautiful?
For example, what sort of answer would you get, if you put the how question to someone who does not believe that the world was created by a person-like Being? (That is, a Being who has intentions, preferences, a plan for how things should go.) In short, what if you address the question, How did the world come to be beautiful? to someone who doesn't believe that the world was deliberately made, but instead brought forth by a much less person-like process?
I will suggest this much: its not so obvious what sort of answer youd get, if you did that. Compared to the answer youd get if put the same question to, for example, the woman who wrote (the real-life, Anglican version of) All Things Bright and Beautiful.
To be continued .
Dont expect an actual answer to the question, Why is the world beautiful? Not in this individual journal entry, at least.
The closest youll get is a quotation of a short text which suggests, or implies, an answer. I wont even explicate, herein, what I think that implied answer is.
So whats the text? Its the refrain of a hymn (Christian; specifically Anglican) called All Things Bright and Beautiful. You may, or may not, have heard of it. Anyway, here it is.
Notes: this was first published in 1848, in a book titled Hymns for Little Children. And if you'd like to see the verses, as well as the refrain, you may consult this Wikipedia page.
If you have some familiarity with bog-standard Christian beliefs, you may be able to come up, on your own, with a reasonable guess as to what is the answer, implied in this text, to the question Why is the world beautiful? Please keep in mind, if you do, that such an implied answer is not necessarily the correct answer to that same Why question.
Because this whole journal entry, up to here, has had the purpose of suggesting, roughly, what the Christian answer to Why is the world beautiful? might be. But thats only a preliminary concern, anyway; I feel no need to pin down, exactly, what the Christian answer is.
Why not? Because my real goal (but beyond the scope of this journal entry) is to explore how the question, Why is the world beautiful? might be answered by someone of a different religion. Really different, not trivially different: not like Judaism, or Islam, or merely a different flavor of Christianity. For this purpose, the religion I will choose, as the other side of the comparison, is Taoism.
(Note, however, that I am really referring to philosophical Taoism, and not the religion of Taoism as it is practiced on the ground in China.)
To sum up: the real question is how might a Taoist sage answer Why is the world beautiful? And I am about to leave you, for now, with only the slightest hint of an answer.
And the hint, in turn, takes the form of yet another rephrasing of the question. How might a thoughtful person answer the Why beautiful question, if that person had grown up singing the following variant of the Christian hymn quoted above?
There's this funny little man who lives inside my head who's always asking me questions. Recently, he asked me one which was tangentially related to my most recent journal entry.
Q: So, you've been having some trouble getting an appointment with a psychiatrist. But why did your doctor refer you to one in the first place?
A: Because I asked him to.
Q: Uh-huh. And why'd you do that, Tom?
A: I've been having some short-term memory issues Like, I go upstairs to get something, and by the time I get there, I've forgotten what the something was.
(That's not entirely a bad thing, of course. I get more exercise that way.)
But it's still, on the whole, a pain in the butt, given that it's been happening more and more often.
Q: You have my sympathy. But you still haven't said why you wanted to see a psychiatrist.
A: Um, I sorta thought that was obvious. I thought maybe a change of medication would help with the memory problems.
He didn't have any more questions, so I guess I'll post this, and go on to the next item on my to-do list.
If only I could remember what that was.
I consider myself to be a victim of something I shall call "psychiatric extortion".
Side remark: I guess that opening line, read without context, would qualify as the exact opposite of clickbait.
Rather than trying to define the term, I shall simply describe the example.
Background: I am already seeing a psychotherapist. My primary care physician referred me to a psychiatrist for consultation about medication.
A couple of weeks later, I received a phone call from someone representing a psychiatric practice. (A group practice, I presume.) The important part of the interaction was roughly as follows:
She: We have a therapy requirement. You have to have ten sessions with one of our therapists.
I: I'm already seeing a therapist. Perhaps y'all can coordinate with him, instead?
She: No. It has to be one of ours. (She didn't actually say "It's our policy," but she might as well have done.)
I: made some semi-articulate noises about not being happy about such a requirement.
She: Okay, we'll let your primary care practice know that they'll need to refer you to someone else.
End of conversation. I would welcome any questions or comments you may have.
So far, I have watched not quite half of "Bohemian Rhapsody," the recent film with a central character named "Freddie Mercury." The idea of finishing the thing fills me with revulsion, so I probably won't.
Yes, I am aware that "Freddie Mercury" is also the name of a real person, one with some biographical details similar to the one in the movie. I don't know, however, whether this Freddiethe one played, here, by Rami Malekactually resembles the real one, in any fundamental way. And I don't care; the reactions I am expressing are to "movie Freddie" ("MF", for short.)
I think MF is a disgusting human being.
One might jump to the conclusion that I am being homophobic. But I don't think I am.
How do I defend myself against this charge? Like this:
The character of MF does, in some ways, match one stereotype of gay men. But that's not a full description of his personality. He has some additional traits that are not part of the stereotype. Most notably, he's a malignant narcissist.
Think: one part flamboyantly gay, one part Donald Trump. It's the combination of the two that I really don't like or at least, I can't stand the idea of subjecting myself to any more of a movie centered on him.
Do remember, though, that I feel this way only about "movie Freddie," and not (so far as I know) about the real Freddie Mercury. And not, I hope it goes without saying, about Rami Malek, either.
In my most recent journal entry, I said that I would draft a resignation speech for president Trump.
I haven't done that, and I'm not going to. Why not?
I wasn't planning on a parody. I thought I could come up with something plausible. I even had an idea in mind of what that would be.
And now a second disappointment: not only am I not going to draft the speech, I'm also not going to tell you what the idea was. Frankly, I now think it was embarrassingly naive.
I regret any inconvenience that this may cause.
What to do next? It's not that I don't have ideas; I have plenty of those. But sometimes I get stuck in a seemingly endless loop, trying to choose among them.
So I should pick one, without worrying about whether it's the best possible choice, and just go with it.
Okay, I choose: "Figure out how we, the American people, can get Donald Trump out of office." (Ruled ineligible as an answer, for obvious reasons: "Wait until his term expires.")
How about this, then: "Persuade him to resign."
I know, I know: the first thing you think is that this answer, also, should be thrown out at once. Although for a different reason. You agree that if he resigns, that counts as a way of getting him out of office. But "getting him to resign" is, itself, simply not gonna happn.
You certainly could be right about that, but let's not give up so easily. Let's give serious consideration to the question: "Is there a way that Donald Trump could be persuaded to resign?" (And no, I'm not talking about threats.)
Instead, try this: draft an announcement of his resignation, designed for him to read on television. Make it so that when he looks at the proposed wording, he says to himself:
You know, with this kind of wind behind my back, I'll really be going out on top! Much better than hanging around the dingy old White House, and putting up with all the bullshit.
I'll whip up a first draft, and post it in my next journal entry. Then y'all can let me know whether you think it might fly.
Back on February 28, I posted, in "Talk Politics", with the subject line Global Mourning. I have come to realize that some of what I said there was prone to misunderstanding because I think that at least one person did misunderstand it.
I said that my mood, in regard to Donald Trump's War, had shifted from anger to grief. I did already, right there in the text, warn against one possible misunderstanding: while my mood (when thinking about the war) had changed, my judgment on it had not. Though I was feeling grief more than the earlier anger, I still disapproved of Trump's having started the war, as much as I ever did. (And still do now, if not more so.)
In short, feelings and judgments are not the same thing.
Now I want to add: the shift in feelings is, itself, not necessarily permanent. One can shift from grief back to anger, and then back to grief again, while one's judgment remains unchanged all the while.
In fact, I have made that shift in the interim, several times. I have thought up, and written down, some allegedly clever things on the subject that were prompted largely by anger. (But I have not, as yet, seen fit to post them publicly.)
While I'm on the subject, I might as well add: anger and grief are by no means a complete list of the emotions that one might feel, and I have felt, in response to this disastrous war. There's also depression, for one.
And fear! I was astounded when I realized that I'd left that one out!
As you probably know, yesterdaySaturday, February 28the United States and Israel commenced a war against Iran, with one of the stated objectives being to overthrow the government of that country.
And I posted something about it yesterday, too … but not here in my own journal; it's in the community journal called "talk politics". It has the subject line "global mourning", and you can find it here:
My last few journal entries have been about the adventures of the current US president. For a change of pace, here's something about nice people.
It's three pages and a bit, and you will find it here:
Kindness Without Religious Faith
Religious faith, or its absence, is a stage-setting device. The core subject is kindness, itself.
We are introduced to a young fella who has grown up to be a genuinely nice, kind person. One day, he suddenly finds himself baffled by the question: "Why am I kind?
Don't expect a definitive answer about him, nor about kind people in general. I'll be happy if it gets you thinking about the question.
I refer you back to my Dreamwidth journal entry of January 8, which has the subject line Should the USA invade Greenland?
Full credit for the humorous wording belongs to late night television host Stephen Colbert. My quotation from one of his monologues ends with "They're insane!", where "they" appears to refer to the people of the United States. Since Colbert is a US American himself, as am I, this statement may raise some eyebrows: does he, and do I, actually regard our own country, taken as a whole, as insane?
I don't. It's a great line in the Late Show context, and I am not criticizing Colbert for using it, but if you take it seriously and literally …
Based strictly on newsworthy recent events in our country, I can think of one individual who is far more clearly qualified to be called insane than is the average American. That would be our president.
During the first week of 2026, Denmark’s prime minister warned that an American attack on Greenland would cause the end of NATO. She may very well have been correct.
Of course, I hope we never find out: I hope that our government never actually does anything so insane.
But is that what would happen, in the event of such a blunder? It certainly might, as I said, but I think it’s unnecessarily pessimistic to regard it as certain. There’s at least one other possible outcome, and I think it would be a better one:
The rest of NATO could expel the United States from the organization.
Or, if that’s not technically feasible, and NATO, as such, has to be dissolved, then the civilized countries among its former members could form a new organization, identical in its basic purpose, with a different name.
Okay, the topic title is clickbait. Like, I make it sound like I think that this is a serious question, open for debate on the pros and cons. I don't. Stephen Colbert put it in perspective. This is an approximation of what he said: The NATO charter clearly says that any attack on a NATO member shall be treated, by all members, as an attack against all. So that means that, if we attack Greenland, we'll be obligated to go to war against ... ourselves! Gee, that's scary. You really don't want to go to war with the United States. They're insane!